The issue of royalties for authoring and invention is a newly
emerged phenomenon that is recently brought up in legal circles
worldwide, and the governments are facing challenges in devising
lasting regulations for designating the relation between producers and
consumers of intangible and cultural products.
Since its advent, Islam has fortunately solved this problem by
presenting logical and equitable executive approaches. With a glance
at the background and the history of royalties in western countries,
Iran, and the Islamic culture and after defining scientific
circumstances of legal examination of current problems, the writer of
the present paper has attempted to introduce both positive and
negative viewpoints of Muslim lawyers andjurists, whether Sunni and
Shi"ite, on the issue of royalties.
Having narrated and criticized the opinions and proofs of the
proponents and opponents, the writereventuallyconcludes- in view
of legal decisions (fatwās) of the contemporary authorities,
particularly Imam Khomeini(ra) - that the prevailing royalty is not
among external and tangible objects. Similarly, the right to
appropriateand regard it as propertyis viewedas suspiciousby the
majority of jurists and the permission to sell it to the publishers in
forms of legal sale would be problematic and requires further
deliberation. However, there is no restriction for bequeathing and
transferring material and intangible rights of such cultural products as
books, cassettes, CD"s, and software programs, in terms of legal
compromise and mutual settlement.
As asserted by some contemporary jurists including Imam
Khomeini (ra), the solution to this problem must be sought in the
conditions of contract required for allocating copyrights for the
publishers and the authors when providing such cultural products for
sale.