The Dilemma of Reincarnation and its Solution in Al-Razi’ s Theory of Perfection of the Soul

Q: How can I download an article?

To download an article from SID, first log in to the site, search for the article title, and click on the 'Download Article' option.

Q: How can I download an ISI article?

To download an ISI article on SID, enter the keyword or article title in the search bar, view the relevant results, click on the desired article, and select the 'Download Article' option.

Q: How can I access the SID database?

To access the SID database, visit SID.ir, create an account, and log in to access scientific resources.

Q: Is downloading articles from SID free?

Some articles on SID are available for free, while others require payment. Details are specified on the article's page.

FARAMARZ QARAMALEKI AHAD; Montasseri Mohammad Mehdi; BARKHORDARI ZEINAB

مرکز اطلاعات علمی Scientific Information Database (SID) - Trusted Source for Research and Academic Resources

Journal Paper

Paper Information

Journal: JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL THEOLOGICAL RESEARCH Year:2020 | Volume:22 | Issue:2 (84) Page(s): 5-26

Download Full-Text

Persian Verion

View:

506

Download:

Cites:

Information Journal Paper

Title

The Dilemma of Reincarnation and its Solution in Al-Razi’ s Theory of Perfection of the Soul

Author(s)

FARAMARZ QARAMALEKI AHAD | Montasseri Mohammad Mehdi | BARKHORDARI ZEINAB | Issue Writer Certificate

Keywords

Muhammad b.Zakariya al-RaziQ1

the perfection of the soulQ1

ReasonQ2

AnimalQ1

reincarnationQ2

Abstract

Muhammad Ibn Zakariya al-Razi, the famous physician and philosopher of the Islamic world, has been considered by many researchers in different aspects. His theory of perfection of the soul, however, is not much appreciated in recent scholarship. Without learning philosophy, he believes the soul cannot be perfected and released from the body after death. This proposition begs the question: What will be the fate of the soul after death if it is not sufficiently perfected? reincarnation, responds al-Razi. His view on Reason and reincarnation sets forth a dilemma in his philosophy. The conception of reincarnation implies two propositions: (1) only human beings are rational, and (2) the transmigrated soul eventually returns to the human body, so that it once again tries to achieve perfection. These propositions raise two questions: Why is the soul rational in the human body and irrational in Animals? If rationality is an accident for the souls, how does it survive death? This paper aims to provide a flawless solution for this dilemma through a critical analysis method. Before this, previous attempts for achieving such a solution must be investigated. Therese-Anne Druart has suggested that, for al-Razi, Animals have Reason to some extent. Therefore, the soul is rational, whether it is a human soul or that of Animals. Contrarily, Peter Adamson argues that al-Razi has regarded Animals as deprived of Reason, although they can think. Providing six arguments, Adamson argues that al-Razi does not believe in reincarnation. This way, there will be no reincarnation in al-Razi's philosophy to lead him to the dilemma. We propose that neither of the above solutions can solve the dilemma of reincarnation because al-Razi believes in both reincarnation and depriving Animals completely of Reason. He does not regard rationality as a condition for the survival of the soul after death. Al-Razi has been influenced by Plato and also mostly by Galen and is opposed to Aristotle's view on the soul. So, his conception of the soul should be conceived in a Platonic sense, not an Aristotelian one. Accordingly, the soul is an eternal self-mover entity and rationality is not the criterion for the survival of the soul. Besides, al-Razi indicates that a human being's Reason is due to the particular temperance and structure of his body, especially the brain. Consequently, the soul does not need rationality to survive death. Moreover, the nature of the soul is not necessarily rational. Although the view of reincarnation faces many problems, as many Muslim philosophers have criticized it, this investigation can pave the way for further research on the nature of the soul from al-Razi’ s viewpoint.

Cites

No record.

References

No record.

Cite

APA: Copy

FARAMARZ QARAMALEKI, AHAD, Montasseri, Mohammad Mehdi, & BARKHORDARI, ZEINAB. (2020). The Dilemma of Reincarnation and its Solution in Al-Razi’ s Theory of Perfection of the Soul. JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL THEOLOGICAL RESEARCH, 22(2 (84) ), 5-26. SID. https://sid.ir/paper/372018/en

Vancouver: Copy

FARAMARZ QARAMALEKI AHAD, Montasseri Mohammad Mehdi, BARKHORDARI ZEINAB. The Dilemma of Reincarnation and its Solution in Al-Razi’ s Theory of Perfection of the Soul. JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL THEOLOGICAL RESEARCH[Internet]. 2020;22(2 (84) ):5-26. Available from: https://sid.ir/paper/372018/en

IEEE: Copy

AHAD FARAMARZ QARAMALEKI, Mohammad Mehdi Montasseri, and ZEINAB BARKHORDARI, “The Dilemma of Reincarnation and its Solution in Al-Razi’ s Theory of Perfection of the Soul,” JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL THEOLOGICAL RESEARCH, vol. 22, no. 2 (84) , pp. 5–26, 2020, [Online]. Available: https://sid.ir/paper/372018/en

Related Journal Papers