Identify the mechanisms for effective management of incompetency teachers

Q: How can I download an article?

To download an article from SID, first log in to the site, search for the article title, and click on the 'Download Article' option.

Q: How can I download an ISI article?

To download an ISI article on SID, enter the keyword or article title in the search bar, view the relevant results, click on the desired article, and select the 'Download Article' option.

Q: How can I access the SID database?

To access the SID database, visit SID.ir, create an account, and log in to access scientific resources.

Q: Is downloading articles from SID free?

Some articles on SID are available for free, while others require payment. Details are specified on the article's page.

NARENJI THANI FATEMEH; MIRKAMALI SEYYED MOHAMMAD; ASADI SOMAYEH; NOSRATI FATEMEH

Title

Identify the mechanisms for effective management of incompetency teachers

Author(s)

NARENJI THANI FATEMEH | MIRKAMALI SEYYED MOHAMMAD | ASADI SOMAYEH | NOSRATI FATEMEH | Issue Writer Certificate

Keywords

effective management

unqualified teachers

improvement mechanism

qualitative research

Abstract

This study aims to identify effective mechanisms for managing unqualified teachers. The literature review found that the education system still has teachers working in our country and in other countries. It does not have the minimum standards required for teaching positions. The study applied the qualitative approach by using semi-structured interviews to gather data. Since the data were collected based on the lived experience of the interviewees, the research methodology employed is phenomenological. The research field (participants) consisted of three groups of heads of education departments, primary school directors and academic experts in the professional qualifications of teachers. The criterion for selecting the officials of the education departments and the principals of the primary schools was that they were directly involved in implementing the evaluation of the professional qualifications of the teachers and dealing with the unqualified teachers, and they were responsible for this task. The criterion for selecting academic specialists is those who have specialized and theoretical knowledge and who can look at this issue scientifically. Finally, more comprehensive results were obtained by linking scientific and academic aspects to administrative and practical aspects. Finally, the sample members of 19 people, including nine officials of the Education Department of Markazi Province, five primary school principals of Markazi Province and five university education specialists, were purposefully selected and interviewed. The data was analyzed based on the qualitative nature of the information obtained during the interview, extracted similar concepts, and coded (Klaizi method). This process is referred to as protocol phrases, and phrases directly related to the studied phenomenon have been deleted. Indeed, after reviewing each interview, the sections that could be considered the initial code of research objectives were identified and chosen as the initial concept. Then, the typical initial concepts of the top categories were classified as concepts related to the efficient management of unqualified teachers. Finally, the concepts identified were classified into more comprehensive categories. To ensure the validity of the search, four Lincoln and Guba tests were used. The following has been done: (1) A copy of the interview and a summary of the questions asked. The answers given by the respondents were provided to them to find out their reaction at the reporting stage. (2) The researcher tried to spend more time interviewing university experts in the area. 3) The researchers tried to describe the full details of the research, from sampling to data analysis. 4) To verify their validity, the reports and research notes were reviewed by two researchers, and both yielded relatively similar results. (5) To verify the reliability of the findings, all interviews were documented and implemented with accuracy. The data were reduced with summaries and brief notes, the coding principles extracted the data, and the themes were extracted. To evaluate the reliability of the research, two methods of agreement between the two coders (intra-subject agreement) and new reliability (stability index) were used, both of which are reliable. In the first question of the interview, we attempted to answer the question: what are the current attitudes toward unqualified teachers? The interviews on the second question of the research show seventeen types of attitudes by school principals towards unqualified teachers: transfer of unqualified teachers to other schools, appointment to different roles and positions, and transfer to non-qualified positions. The most common methods used with unqualified teachers were voluntary transfer to another school in the same educational district, voluntary transfer to a non-educational place, transfer to another school, and other common strategies. Deportation, dismissal and expulsion were among the most common procedures. As a result, the inadequacy, comprehensiveness and effectiveness of the existing methods necessitate establishing an efficient management system with a long-term and purposeful view, and radical and precise measures in the field of teachers are unnecessary. In the second question of the interview, including the scientific and practical opinions and suggestions of respondents, we attempted to develop a model for how managers deal with unqualified teachers. As a result, four categories of preventive, corrective, monitoring and punitive actions were identified for dealing with unqualified teachers. Preventive actions include; designing an effective recruitment system based on professional competencies, improving the quality of teacher training courses, designing and implementing mechanisms related to culture building, paying attention to motivational factors and environmental health factors, enriching teachers 'jobs, raising teachers' competencies as concerns, identifying challenges, The issue of the incompetence of teachers in a systematic way is the design and implementation of appropriate mechanisms to encourage and support qualified teachers, select and employ skilled managers, planning. Corrective actions include design and implementation of development and improvement courses by colleagues, design and implementation of teacher empowerment programs by educational specialists, design and implementation of teacher empowerment programs with self-development system, design and implementation of teacher empowerment programs by principals and providing feedback on unqualified teachers to himself, the director and officials of the department. Monitoring actions include continuous monitoring and tracking of teacher performance and progress. Finally, punitive measures involve designing and implementing indirect, punitive approaches. As a result, prevention, correction, supervision and punishment mechanisms need to be developed and implemented to manage unqualified teachers effectively.

No record.

APA: Copy

NARENJI THANI, FATEMEH, MIRKAMALI, SEYYED MOHAMMAD, ASADI, SOMAYEH, & NOSRATI, FATEMEH. (2021). Identify the mechanisms for effective management of incompetency teachers. JOURNAL OF SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION, 9(1 ), 180-204. SID. https://sid.ir/paper/961014/en

Vancouver: Copy

NARENJI THANI FATEMEH, MIRKAMALI SEYYED MOHAMMAD, ASADI SOMAYEH, NOSRATI FATEMEH. Identify the mechanisms for effective management of incompetency teachers. JOURNAL OF SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION[Internet]. 2021;9(1 ):180-204. Available from: https://sid.ir/paper/961014/en

IEEE: Copy

FATEMEH NARENJI THANI, SEYYED MOHAMMAD MIRKAMALI, SOMAYEH ASADI, and FATEMEH NOSRATI, “Identify the mechanisms for effective management of incompetency teachers,” JOURNAL OF SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION, vol. 9, no. 1 , pp. 180–204, 2021, [Online]. Available: https://sid.ir/paper/961014/en

No record.

Scientific Information Database

ISSN: 2588-4824

Journal Paper

Identify the mechanisms for effective management of incompetency teachers